Argumenta – Journal of Analytic Philosophy


A Skeptical Approach to the Audibility of Semantic Properties

Issue: • Author/s: Elvira Di Bona
Topics: Philosophy of language, Philosophy of mind

The issue of whether we can auditorily perceive meanings (or semantic properties) expressed in a language we understand has been approached through arguments based either on theoretical reasoning or the discussion of psychological effects. I am skeptical about the use of either type of argument. In this paper, I will first explain the limitations of the standard theoretical argument: the phenomenal contrast method. As for psychological phenomena, I will discuss semantic satiation and the Stroop effect. I will summarize why semantic satiation has already been dismissed and, based on said…